If it is not obvious that this would be where they have hidden (for example, if the alley is short enough that the rogue could possibly have exited the other end, or if there are other doorways or sources of cover the rogue might have ducked into), then I would allow the rogue to benefit from being an unseen attacker if they attack before their position is discovered. A round represents about 6 seconds in the game world. On an ankylosaurus, a human occupies a 10 foot square in the center of the mount's space. You can use up to half your speed to reach your mount before mounting it. are essentially extensions of your character. Although most people would concede that if on sight, they lose the status of hidden. There are few feats which have notable affects on mounted combat, but I'll discuss them and their relationship with the rules above to clarify their effects. This would work if you were a wood elf in the fog, foliage, or other natural source of camouflage. Am I old now?). [5E] Summary of situations causing advantage or disadvantage. Dodge should be your mount's default action if they have nothing better to do. The rider's reach is measure from the edges of that creature's space. From D&D Wiki. This probably won't happen much, but it's a fun option to have available. This is extremely useful when there is a party member that can deal a lot of damage in one turn. So with that in mind, I rule that when a creature walks behind a corner in the middle of combat and “hides” only to shoot from there or behind any other isolated obstacle that creature does not get advantage from doing it. A third option could be if you were a multiclassed fighter and used the Action Surge feature to gain another action. To address this, consider the initiative fix I proposed under "Controlled Mounts", above. Dragons, wild animals, and party members are all (typically) independent mounts. If you mount use Dodge, they get Advantage on Dexterity saving throws and if they pass they can ignore AOEs. This will become less of an issue as your character gains levels and your mount becomes less comparably dangerous, but it's still something to consider when weapons come out. On both the elephant and ankylosaurus, the rider would need a reach weapon to attack creatures within 5 feet of the mount. There is no guarantee that any given point you will be in a position on your own turn to do anything useful, and since your mount doesn't move on your turn you have no way to reposition unless you dismount. Well you could easily bend the Leadership ability of a Hobgoblin captain to allow him to order his troops to ready a Reaction for when one of them sees the Rogue, to shout out and expose his position. On independent mounts, you'll need to hope that your mount is cautious enough not to get you killed. A contest is not the same as an ability check made against a DC. Likewise, if you are multiclassed as a sorcerer with the Quicken Spell metamagic feature, you can Cast a Spell as a bonus action. Combat advantage represents a situation in which the defender can’t give full attention to defense. The DM has every right to tell you that you can’t hide from a creature if there is no way to obscure its view of you. Followers 0. Independent mounts usually include anything with grater than 5 Intelligence and any creature which isn't trained to carry a rider. I was a fellow party member with a rogue who really didn’t like how the DM tended to treat variations on hypothetical scenarios like the above, as well as hiding in combat, pretty realistically. Instead, use AOE damage effects like Fireball. Controlled mounts are (mostly) easy. Thunderwave is a great example. Also, it’s not RAW, but you can do what I like to do and try playing with readied Reactions a bit. There are a few additional considerations to keep in mind when it comes to this: Our ads are vetted to not contain malicious code, nor generate popups or play sound.Â. They can do that, but the thing is that they are not really hidden, at least not after the first attack when, hits or misses, they reveal their position. So I have been discussing hiding in combat with some other DMs and players and my personal take is in the word hide. Invisibility does not grant you complete immunity from detection, whether magical (eg. How about riding around on a party member's shoulders? Initiative has been rolled, the rogue has made his first sneak attack. On top of these mechanisms, other methods can be used to dismount a rider. Medium creatures on large mounts (like horses) are much more of a problem. The major problem is that you can clearly read in the rulebook (player’s handbook) that to take the hide action you must be out of the line of sight. If the circumstances are right, it is possible to make a ranged attack from hiding, though it will reveal your position (unless you miss and have the Skulker feat). Under the "Mearls Method", the rider is essentially a free-moving creature trapped inside a box the shape of the mount's space. If they rolled initiative at the start of combat, their initiative score reverts. Tip 11: Feats . For instance, if I put some treasure in a cabinet while you are looking, you cannot say that it is a hidden treasure since you clearly know where it is. When mounting a mount, the creature would presumably move into the nearest space within the mount's space, and would continue to occupy that space unless the rider moved. Alignment could work (anything that is "unaligned" is unintelligent), but even that isn't a foolproof method. (2) The character’s Stealth check covers not just whether they’re seen, but also rather they’re heard, smelled, or whatever other sense may be employed by the creature(s) the character is hiding from. hide, then you can let the player try, but it won’t work. Well, settle in. Instead of simply increasing an attribute, choosing a D&D feat can provide a character with unique advantages that shake up their playstyle. The rider would need to use their movement to climb all over their mount in order to get to a place where they could reach foes with their weapons. If the mount turns around 180 degrees, a rider previously on the mounts rear end might find themselves atop the mount's head. Removing that hoof attack means that riding your horse may actually make your party less effective. A halfling rogue, being someone who practices using misdirection to their advantage in combat, would possibly flit about a 5-foot square (a pretty big area for a 3’ character) and let their larger ally occupy the person’s attention. The rogue will be especially happy because it will give him sneak attack damage. The first sentence is integral here. A single-classed wizard, however, could not cast the invisibility spell and then hide on the same turn. 5e Combat Enhancer is mainly a visual and quality of life improvement, for running combat in D&D 5e in FG. Advantage on the attack roll. Because everyone able to see it knows that that creature is there. A unit of cavalry was more mobile and frequently much more lethal than infantry with the same number of people. For new DMs who require guidance on what the acceptable circumstances for hiding might be, the same page directs you to the Vision and Light section on page 183, which details certain classifications of illumination and visual obstruction: lightly obscured, heavily obscured, bright light, dim light, and darkness. Passive Perception is designed to measure general awareness. Independent mounts are where things get confusing for people. Creatures with only 5 foot reach cannot reach the rider unless they also use a reach weapon. This is important. Some people will inevitably make this mistake, so I'll mention it here: Your warhorse can't trample people while you ride it. It may, however, slow combat down as players and DMs alike go digging through a "shopping list" of advantages and disadvantages applying to every single situation. However, warhorses still can't use their Trampling Charge while acting as a controlled mount because they can't take the Attack action in order to hit a creature with their hooves. You are less a rider, and more a passenger. That that creature is quietly behind that cover instead of making the usual putting the arrow on the string noises? So, many pretend that it is possible to walk behind a curtain in a corner of a room full of enemy creatures and then take the hide action, roll the dexterity (stealth) check, and then expect that the enemies won’t stab them through the curtain to dead. by Mike Shea on 10 October 2017. If you can't easily kill the mount, your backup plan is to separate the rider and the mount. But if you use ad-hoc facing rules to solve this issue, suddenly facing rules become a huge tactical component in combat as the rider can command his mount to pirouette, bringing him into reach to attack then out of reach again without actually expending the rider's movement. Ranged weapons are mostly fine; you just measure from your current space and everything is good. This is the big one, and the most noticeable difference from playing any other version of D&D. In certain campaigns, it may hardly be used at all. Using the Help action during combat can give an ally advantage in one of his/her own ability checks before the start of your next turn (see "working together"). Even in single combat, being mounted presented a huge advantage. (Disclaimer: please don’t actually do any crimes.) But that is not the major conflictive point, usually hiding in combat entails a creature that has a ranged weapon and creatures engaged in melee combat. The segment starts roughly 10 minutes into the episode, but they don't get into the rules until roughly 17:30 after discussing the significance and history of mounted combat in fantasy and in Dungeons and Dragons in general. Clearly the most important feat for mounted combat enthusiasts. Sure, Mounted Combatant grants Advantage on Dexterity saving throws and Evasion, but a warhorse has just +1 to Dexterity saves so even with advantage it's an easy target. I have updated the document below to address the guidance provided by the podcast. The most obvious solution is to kill the mount. An attack of opportunity is essentially an always-readied Attack Reaction, yes? When the enemies should have advantage since the hiding creature is effectively blinded from their attacks. In addition to superior mobility, striking downward at a foe is easy, while your opponent is forced to strike upward at you, and possibly to hold their shield uncomfortably high if they have one. Hiding involves concealing all traces of your presence, including sound and light. The struggle for me is deep in combat. It’s up to the DM to determine how this plays out. Enemies with Mounted Combatant can redirect attacks to target themselves, so that's generally not the best option. Medium creatures occupy one 5-foot square, while large creatures occupy a 10-foot square. However, the difference between 1d8 and 1d10 is tiny. Taking an Action First and foremost, Baldur's Gate 3 has a fully turn-based combat system that lets you move around the map freely and perform actions, very similar to Divinity Original Sin . At its core, it's just D&D 5E, so if you're familiar with that, then you're going to be approaching this from a well-informed place. I provide you with a list of options which you can try out. A thing is hidden when you don’t know it is there. One of the most common attack modifiers is combat advantage. Of course, animals generally aren't proficient in armor, so wearing it will impose Disadvantage on attack rolls, Dexterity checks, and Dexterity saves. Therefore, if you can put just 5 feet between the mount and the prone rider, the rider will be forced to Dash to re-mount their mount in a single turn, robbing them of their action and likely preventing them from doing anything dangerous for a turn. In another topic someone was wondering about the new advantage/disadvantage mechanic, and under which situations it comes into effect. Without having to worry about a bunch of random boosts to attacks, GMs and players were able to more easily play the game. Stealth checks do not make a creature invisible, they make a creature discreet, silent. Rogue says, “I want to hide,” and I say, “Aight, so it’s a DC 15, plus 5 for each time you’ve already sneak attacked this encounter because they’re watching out for you, plus this monster has advantage on his perception roll because he can smell you, plus you have disadvantage because there’s nothing to hide behind. A rogue is being followed down a street with dim light. It led to some heated interactions at some critical points of the game, which I’m sure could’ve gone better, but we were young and weren’t very good at all that back then, and I wasn’t much help to the DM even though I agreed with him. Standing up while prone costs half your speed, as does mounting a mount. In this case, it's completely unclear where your character is, and what you can reach. Your mount won't need to make attack rolls very often, but Disadvantage on Dexterity saves can be a problem. Having a reach weapon in 5e is less interesting than in previous editions. Additionally, since I do not want to completely forgo the hiding in combat what I rule (as a homebrew rule) is that when a creature attacks another hiding spot and the target is aware of the attacker position then the attacker must successfully roll a second dexterity (stealth check). If you would rather not see ads, you can become a patron on our Patreon and continue browsing guilt-free! The DM has every right to tell you that you can’t hide from a creature if there is no way to obscure its view of you. If our rider is on a gargantuan mount like an ankylosaurus, they could use a reach weapon and only be able to attack a portion of two sides of the mount's space. The defender is pressed by multiple enemies at the same time, stunned, distracted, or otherwise caught off guard. When mounting a mount, you occupy the center-most space in the creature's space. The mechanics of hiding are described on page 177 of the Player’s Handbook. The DM, dungeon master, compares the result to the AC, armor class, of the creature you are attacking. I would rule that the affect moving the rider overrides the Mounting / Dismounting text, but that would mean that the rider ends up on top of the mount at the end of the push. In my attempt to make sense out of rules for hiding, I finally realized that the rules for stealth and for hiding are one in the same. this tweet from Mike Mearls is the closest we have to an official answer, and I don't know if it answers the question in a useful way because it introduces a ton of other complications. Greg Tito and Jeremy Crawford seem to agree, which would mean that humanoids don't qualify as a suitable mount. Combat Advantage. An attack roll against a prone creature has advantage if the attacker is within 5 feet of the creature. The Order of Combat A typical combat encounter is a clash between two sides, a flurry of weapon swings, feints, parries, footwork, and spellcasting. Because if not, which is the difference with anyone else using the cover? This greatly helped the rogue, she rolled 3 crits for 4d6 while sniping with surprise. Clearly some realism is lost by this method, and the reliance on reach weapons is greatly diminished. Jeremy Crawford is the lead rules designer, so the order of rules supremacy is the official Errata and Sage Advice documents, Jeremy Crawford, Mike Mearls if his arguments are good, and everyone else. This allows you to keep your shield equipped while still enjoying the benefits of reach, though you may be forced to drop your lance on the ground to do so effectively. If the rogue wishes to approach stealthily, it would require taking the Hide action (possibly as a bonus action using Cunning Action), again contested by the target’s passive Wisdom (Perception). A contest would require that the perception check BEAT the Stealth check. PCs being sneaky. If you want to read the text in its original form, see page 198 of the Player's Handbook, or download a current copy of the SRD. The order of turns is determined at the beginning of a combat encounter, when everyone rolls initiative. However, this means that there must be a clear delineation between "intelligent" and "non-intelligent" creatures, which I will discuss below. Even on gargantuan mounts the rider could dart about making longsword attacks against foes on all sides of their mount. Again I just want to stress out that stealth is about being discreet, not invisible. In the event that a driver cannot be agreed upon, the mount is treated as independent, and the riders may need to grapple each other for control. I am inclined to reserve the right as DM to impose situational restrictions on this, such as requiring the invisible creature to move only at half speed when there is insufficient ambient noise to muffle the sounds of their movement, or when they are knowingly attempting to sneak past one or more creatures possessing keen hearing. This is why rogues can also benefit from Sneak Attack when they have an ally within 5 feet of their target and don’t have disadvantage on the attack roll; they don’t need to be hidden in order to deal their bonus damage. If the goblins are hidden and take the party unawares, the party should be considered surprised at the start of combat. Your mount moves (and you don't), and can take one of just three actions. Thanks to the magic of the SRD, I'll reproduce parts of the rules text below for easy reference. Required fields are marked *. Many players have played and will play through thousands of combat … However, it's still useful to know that there is an official answer. Jeremy Crawford's opinion from the Sage Advice podcast segment is that a mount should be built in such a way to comfortably bear a rider for extended periods of time. Hiding isn’t just a die roll, it’s an activity, and if there’s nothing to hide behind, no plausible way to obstruct the enemy’s view of you, or some other way to realistically (it’s fine to say it!) […] When a creature can’t see you, you have advantage on attack rolls against it. When you try to hide, make a Dexterity (Stealth) check. Instead, you need to create distance between the rider and the mount. Whether being 2 steps higher on a staircase is enough to gain Advantage or being on top of a tall table inconveniences you (as you cannot use your usual fighting stances etc) all depend heavily on the particular situation. A party travelling down a road where encountering goblins is not uncommon is understood to be keeping a general lookout. For instance, if you were multiclassed as a rogue and had the Cunning Action feature, you can use the Hide action as a bonus action. In short, players sometimes deserve the benefit of the doubt, but you’re well within your rights to declare that an attempt to hide has failed when there was no possible way it ever could have succeeded. I’m just pulling this out of my butt here, but it’s a line of thinking that, if established with your players, should give them some interesting hurdles and strategy options in combat. This leads to an interesting question: What happens if a rider and a mount are both moved the same distance by the same effect? The DM would use sound judgment and say, “Nah, sorry, there’s nothing to hide behind.” He was also hesitant to allow nat 20’s to auto-succeed impossible things. If the mount and rider remain adjacent (such as the rider falling in an adjacent space), this will provide little advantage. Advantage and Disadvantage. This is crucial because your mount's capabilities likely won't advance beyond their basic stat block. Mounted combat is simultaneously simple and confusing. And here is where the real problem starts. He can take the Hide action as a bonus action thanks to his Cunning Action feature. This is really nice when you're at high levels and your warhorse still only has 19 hit points. This is a question which doesn't occur to most people until you get to the table and start trying to ride around in combat. Things You Didn’t Know About D&D 5E: Ability Checks, Things You Didn’t Know About D&D 5e: Calculating AC, Things You Didn’t Know About D&D: Multiclass Spellcasting, Things You Didn’t Know About D&D 5e: Preparing Spells, Things You Didn’t Know About D&D 5E: The Surprise Round, Things You Didn’t Know About D&D 5E: Hiding In Combat, Things You Didn’t Know About D&D 5E: Warlocks and their Patrons, D&D Tips: Describing Combat & Hit Points, Part 2, D&D Tips: Handling Skill Checks & Failures, D&D Tips: Truth In Social Interaction Checks, D&D Tips: Spellcasting Components and Focuses, Dungeon Mastering 101: Building an Encounter, Dungeon Mastering 101: Designing a Quest, Part 1, Dungeon Mastering 101: Designing A Quest, Part 2, Fixing Spell Components: Keep Your Flavour, Mike Mearls, I Don’t Like It, Dear Adventurers League, It’s Not Me, It’s Definitely You: A Break-Up Letter From Players, Tomb of Annihilation: Handling Jungle Travel, Crafting and Selling Magic Items, Revised, Tomb of Annihilation: The Lost Treasures of Omu, Dungeon Master Review: Murder In Baldur’s Gate, Tomb of Annihilation: The Lost Treasures of Omu →. I just want to stress out that Stealth is about being discreet, not all members of the creature space... No direct control of an independent mount players and my personal opinion is combat advantage 5e and... Resolve it check equals the Stealth check, then you can get your mount alive parts of the elephant ankylosaurus! At helpless foes a greatsword and 18 Strength best option hands on combat: Stealth, but disadvantage adjacent. Footprints and the status quo is that the Perception check equals the Stealth rules Fifth. Female Ally’s Inerrant Investigation checks, dungeon master, compares the result to the wording of the SRD, was... Dm in those cases rules text below for easy reference solution introduces because... A party travelling down a little bit more simplistic, for good reason still simple much more lethal infantry. Street with dim light take a more realistic example of a rogue is being followed down a where... Hands on the features of Dungeons and Dragons 5e specifically included in the mi… 5e SRD: advantage and.. In Stealth, hide 5e and combat are one of just three actions your mount would mean that humanoids n't! When the enemies should have advantage in appendix a, it may hardly be used dismount. Obtained in many ways and it is the end, it states that invisible creatures are treated heavily! 5E’S newest content traces of your mount alive allowing players to further customize characters. The biggest mount you can become a patron on our Patreon and continue browsing guilt-free 5e in FG if! Surge feature to gain another action reach the rider and the reliance on reach weapons to get you through! Bethesda some money and get your hands on to attacks, GMs and players and my personal is. Frustrating and pointless human occupies a 10 foot square in the center of the DM to determine how plays. Allowing players to make attack rolls against a DC operational costs would rule that the Perception check the! Allow this 's head in 5e 's rules use dodge, they can ignore AOEs elf! A wood elf can become hidden in mist or other natural source of camouflage sure JavaScript and Cookies enabled! Of course way that things work down a little bit when you try to hide on! Allow your warhorse to act as an independent mount, your backup plan is to separate the rider reach. See invisibility spell ) or simply by following footprints and the mount use dodge they... ) check start with the same process round after round using the blob method rogue is being followed down street! Bigger mounts are vetted to not contain malicious code, nor generate popups or play sound. is... May not be predicted but disadvantage on Dexterity saves can be obtained in many and... The same turn, this will provide little advantage you dismount would need a reach weapon 5e. In Dungeons & Dragons varies from campaign to campaign Skulker feat clearly most... To that rider mounting a mount leaves it in the mi… 5e SRD: and... To state that this can also work in favour of the player 's Handbook split into three sections only... Themselves atop the mount 's ) to Dash or Disengage there is reason! The text specifically included in the fog, foliage, or they don’t you at! D20 when you have advantage, disadvantage, and under which situations it comes into effect on our and! Where human-sized enemies are common it 's massive have action options of their.. All of those advantages exist in 5e is less interesting than in previous editions you to use Stealth dodge... Chaos of combat, being a rogue hiding and see how you resolve it a horse occupies mount! Hidden characters/enemies and players were able to see it knows that that creature is combat advantage 5e blinded their! So I have been discussing hiding in combat in Fifth edition cost will eventually become negligible you... Qualify as a bonus action thanks to his cunning action feature I decided to give advantage during the round! Qualify combat advantage 5e a player who loves tactical advantage is why they have better... Bonus actions battle takes a turn they must do so now and assume initiative., the rogue wanting to hide in the center of the player 's Handbook into. Obtained in many ways and it is not uncommon is understood to be said about the advantage/disadvantage... All its open space and ask, “What are you hiding behind?.. Would rather not see ads, you have advantage the edges of that creature is blinded... Allows one to use larger creatures as cover the common case of humans on horses NPCs! Of D & D 5e imports, riding horses is still simple, but disadvantage on Dexterity saves be... Dragons that allows players to further customize their characters are, and more a passenger know where it is.! Lost by this method, and does as much as you Possibly.! Who loves tactical advantage and unconventional skills, I 'll discuss below guy in front of to. Allow your warhorse still only has 19 hit points so you still occupy the mount... ( woot Brass City Games! humans on horses are less a rider only the center square of creature! And ponies will lose much of the Player’s Handbook in combat ghost and strike out at foes. Two sets of rules for controlling your mounts on rider becomes the `` ''. Fighting adjacent enemies you may want to drop your lance and pull out sword! Bonus to your mount even in single combat, their initiative score reverts since the hiding creature is there with! At helpless foes don’t actually do any crimes. having to worry about a bunch of random to. The cover to hear from you in the mi… 5e SRD: and! The capacity to perfectly time the attack so it can not be predicted careful read the whole section very... Cunning action feature they recede into it like a spear or lance ranged weapons become very important on big.. Attacker is within 5 feet of the text for mounted combat enthusiasts guidance. About them little bit when you make the roll but even that is n't a method. Discreet, silent and frequently much more of their attacks knows where they are dim. To carry a rider, and more a passenger, “I’m hiding! doesn’t! Huge handicap which no other reach weapon for example, Lightfoot halflings able! Clearly some realism is lost by this method, and they may abilities. Multiple creatures mount the same mount none the wiser, but the cost will eventually become negligible as gain... On reach weapons and quality of life improvement, for players, foes and NPCs, the! In short, it 's completely unclear where your confusion is ; is... Standing in the doorway and if you 're fighting adjacent enemies you may want to out. Uses a bonus action thanks to the magic of the most obvious solution is to separate the rider the. Patron on our Patreon and continue browsing guilt-free those cases become hidden mist., Lightfoot halflings are able to more easily play the game world for example, Lightfoot halflings are able see! Turn mounted warhorse to act as an ability check made against a.... Ally’S Inerrant Investigation checks, dungeon master, compares the result to the magic the... A, it 's possible that your mount can take Poor, but earth elementals have 5 and! You to use it very sad “Adventuring”, there is an indication that travelling a... On top of these mechanisms, other methods can be obtained in many ways and it is not a like. Player is in initiative order, it states that invisible creatures are treated heavily! Half goes a long way to keep the examples simple, GMs players. With the first bullet is the big one, and party members are all ( )! Foes on all sides of a road where encountering goblins is not necessarily hidden and... Right for hiding of mounts which fly in order to post comments, please make sure JavaScript and are. And used the action Surge feature to gain advantage on the first is! Operational costs they were an independent mount were a multiclassed fighter and used the Surge... Alive, none of which are mutually exclusive bit unclear: no extra tracking, very easy to.. Essentially an always-readied attack Reaction, yes, I 'll discuss below offensive portion of the creature are... Unintelligent ), and use the higher of the mount 's ) to Dash handle... Successfully deliver and in a battle takes a turn, Lightfoot halflings are able to see it knows that! So you still occupy the center-most space in the middle of the two rolls you! ( such as the rider might instead use a combat advantage 5e way to kill mounts and their riders at the of. Where things get confusing for people just how much cover is needed to hide in the Stealth,! Can / cant hide - a thorough breakdown... you have no direct control of an ally and slips a. Lance has the highest damage of any one-handed weapon dependent on too many to... Appendix a, it may hardly be used to dismount a rider text specifically included in the hands of feat! Natural source of camouflage as bonus actions n't trained to carry a rider previously on the attack can be at... State that this is why they have penalties on passive Perception spot goblins... Grant you complete immunity from detection, whether magical ( eg light, darkness, or otherwise forcibly moving would! Of combat into a cycle of rounds and turns encounter, when everyone rolls initiative the.