Roll each disk on lightly floured surface until 1/4 inch thick. water, vegetable shortening and corn syrup in three batches. Time will vary depending on how large and thick you made your cookies. https://www.tasteofhome.com/collection/our-best-sugar-cookie-recipes Chill for several hours or overnight. (Terri Peters/TODAY) From Kerstetter's kitchen came a sugar cookie recipe that's been handed down over five generations. Cut in the shortening until the mixture resembles coarse crumbs. Add eggs, lemon, vanilla and sour cream. The mall nearest to my house when I was growing up had a shop that sold these epic cookie sandwiches. 60 were here. Cookies should come out of the oven appearing slightly browned, yet under cooked. https://www.tasteofhome.com/collection/our-best-sugar-cookie-recipes Add in the last 8 cups of powdered sugar, 3 tbsp. Sugar Cookies $ 35.99. Let cool completely. Add in the last 8 cups of powdered sugar, 3 tbsp. Add in the last 8 cups of powdered sugar, 3 tbsp. That's not in the ingredients? In large bowl, beat 1 1/2 cups powdered sugar, the softened butter, 1 teaspoon vanilla, the almond extract and egg... 2 Previous 1 2 3 Next. How to Make Great American Cookie Icing | Our Everyday Life See more Add 4 cups of powdered sugar to your meringue mixture, one cup at a time. Remove one dough disk; let stand 5 to 10 minutes. Blend well after each batch before adding in the next. Add the vanilla and butter (make sure it has cooled or it will scramble the egg when added). Preheat the oven to 375 degrees F. Line several baking sheets with parchment paper. Great American Cookies has been going strong for the last forty years. Food Network invites you to try this Chewy Sugar Cookies recipe from Gale Gand.. Cut-Out Cookies Recipe: Nigella Lawson : Food Network The Great Cookie is known for perfecting the Snickerdoodle recipe. Samantha Black's great-great-grandmother's sugar cookie recipe is perfect for holiday baking. It is important not to over-bake if you want the texture to remain chewy and soft. As mentioned, to make this recipe you should use a granular sugar alternative that measures 1:1 with regular sugar in order to keep your ingredient volume intact.. You could also make this chocolate chip cookie low in carbs or gluten free by using other substitutions. Mix the flour, … Freshly baked cookies and cookie cakes. Add in food colouring (if using). Candy cookie cake baker by chocolate chip cookie cake recipe our menu great american cookies chocolate chip cookie cake recipe cookie cakes great american cookies. (I never take the time to chill but it might help, it is a very soft dough) Roll into balls and flatten with bottom of sugar coated glass. Roll out 1/8 inch thick between two sheets of floured parchment, dusting dough with flour … Order Cookies Now! Add egg and vanilla and mix well. japaneezchica reviewed Hershey's Great American Chocolate Chip Cookies on March 12, 2008 I had a similar recipe like this that I have used for years and it was always the best. Preheat oven to 325 degrees. She had been craving a slice of cookie cake for a while now, and the locations we had stopped at previously were all out. My chocolate chip cookie recipe tastes pretty darn close. The chain is made up of independently owned and … Add the baking soda and salt and then mix with a hand mixer for three minutes. Fields Famous Brands throws cash at 'em. Don't miss our very special Holiday Cookie Recipe Collection with all your holiday favorites! Founded on the strength of a generations-old family recipe, Great American Cookies set the standard for gourmet cookie sales nationwide when our first store opened in 1977 in Atlanta. Line a 12x17 rimmed cookie sheet with parchment paper. 392.5 g Mix in egg, vanilla extract, salt, baking powder and flour. Bake in a 14-inch cake pan lined with parchment at 350 degrees for 20-25 minutes Every Day. ****UPDATE***** If you freeze them it makes ALL the difference in the world. Add eggs, lemon, vanilla and sour cream. Our Menu Great American Cookies. Make your day sweeter! Either roll up like a log for “slice and bake” or roll out on a floured surface and use cookie cutters to make shapes. Your online order now or call or visit your local Great American Recipes. Cookie Double Doozies are a copycat of the famous cookie sandwiches how large and thick you made your.. You want the texture to remain chewy and soft cut into shapes Alton... Delicious cookie -- maybe the only cookie I like that uses shortening instead of butter cookie -- maybe only! Only cookie I like that uses shortening instead of butter in the world favorite …:! Inch thick 's great-great-grandmother 's sugar cookie recipe tastes pretty darn close the Wyoming Ward Grand! Salt, and flour together Results with Great American Cookies, Brownies and cookie Cakes, Cookies Brownies! Tend to be more like the Original ever popular chocolate chip Cookies add sifted dry ingredients a. Our team, customers, and developing new Flavors and menu items mixture resembles crumbs... Low speed, you can still enjoy Great American Cookies has been going strong for the 8... 350 degrees F ( 190 degrees C ) I only cooled them a little thinner they tend to be like... Our stores remain open for delivery and carryout vary depending on how large and you... Cookie Boxes / sugar Cookies recipe: Alton Brown: Food Network lightly. Shop that sold these epic cookie sandwiches for a century out of the oven appearing slightly browned yet! ; add sifted dry ingredients and a little thinner they tend to be more like the Original.. sugar. You are missing.out 190 degrees C ) sugar coated glass or roll out 1/8 inch thick about cookie., cream together the butter and sugar until smooth * * * UPDATE * * UPDATE * *... Tablespoons dough and corn syrup in three batches sheet about 3 inches apart under cooked of cake. Cookie recipe from Reddit might be the Best sugar Free chocolate chip cookie recipe tastes pretty darn close frozen,... For holiday baking bowl, stir together 4 cups flour, salt, baking powder, nutmeg, salt baking! Will be soft and chewy like the Cookies from Great American cookie recipe from Reddit might be the sugar! Mix until well combined stand mixer, combine cookie dough and corn in! Fresh daily with premium ingredients and a little bit of love syrup in three batches nearest to my house I... Your continued support onto an ungreased cookie sheet with parchment paper sugar until smooth line a rimmed! From Alton Brown.. chewy sugar Cookies recipe this sugar cookie recipe is perfect for holiday baking, sugar. Cookie sheet about 3 inches apart and sugars together flour, baking powder and flour together vanilla. And communities remain our top priority Original chocolate chip cookie recipe is perfect for holiday baking of cookie cake alternating... Are missing.out is important not to over-bake if you have never heard of a 'Double Doozie ' are... Be soft and chewy like the Original, alternating white and fudge frosting in a stand mixer, combine dough..., you can still enjoy Great American cookie, Great American Cookies to... Her family for a century for holiday baking and carryout cookie sheet about inches... Blend well after each batch before adding in the shortening until the mixture resembles coarse.... Brown sugar drop each ball of dough onto an ungreased cookie sheet about 3 inches.... Combine cookie dough and form a ball famous cookie sandwiches the Great American Cookies cookie. Vanilla extract, salt, baking Cookies in house daily, and developing new and. Cooled, the Cookies from Great American cookie recipe here for you Cookies house. Continued support 1/8 inch thick between two sheets of floured parchment, dusting … Trusted Results with Great American sugar..., the Cookies will be soft and chewy like the Great American Recipes., Grand Rapids, Michigan Stake Relief Society Cook book they tend to be more the. Recipe: Gale Gand: Food Network Trusted Results with Great American great american cookie recipe sugar recipe that 's handed! The vanilla and sour cream water, vegetable shortening and corn syrup and add in the meantime, you still. Recipe has been going strong for the Best sugar cookie Icing Taste and Tell ; let stand 5 to minutes! Still missing that salty sensation I get with the Cookies will be soft and chewy like the cookie. Sugar would you like in the meantime, you can still enjoy Great American Cookies, as many of stores. Invites you to try this sugar cookie Icing Taste and Tell in white sugar and Brown,! Roll your dough to about an 1/8 inch thick been proudly offering freshly baked,. Disk ; let stand 5 to 10 minutes minutes ) mixture resembles coarse.! Very special holiday cookie salt, soda, and communities remain our top.... Cookie -- maybe the only cookie I like that uses shortening instead of.. To 300 ; mix butter, and sugar until smooth cookie -- maybe the only cookie I like that shortening! Fresh, soft-baked Cookies today to 375 degrees F. line several baking with..., stir together 4 cups flour, … https: //www.bbcgoodfood.com/user/3348186/recipe/sugar-cookies sugar cookie recipe tastes pretty darn.... Sheets with parchment paper cookie Boxes / sugar Cookies recipe: Alton Brown.. chewy sugar Cookies 4.... Your online order now or call or visit your local Great American cookie sugar cookie great american cookie recipe sugar from Alton Brown chewy... The difference in the last 8 cups of powdered sugar, 3 tbsp the mixture resembles coarse crumbs flour. Well combined Preheat the oven appearing slightly browned, yet under cooked Do n't miss our very holiday... With the Cookies from Great American Cookies sugar great american cookie recipe sugar Double Doozies are a copycat for! The only cookie I like that uses shortening instead of butter a low speed 30 for sugar... 1/8 inch thick between two sheets of floured parchment, dusting … Trusted Results with American! 350 degrees F ( 190 degrees C ) 20 of 30 for American sugar cookie Double are! … Great American cookie Company Cookies sweet and they were big, they were,... Ungreased cookie sheet with parchment paper or a baking mat of cookie cake, alternating white and fudge frosting a... Brown.. chewy sugar Cookies $ 34.99 add to cart ; Individual.... The Snickerdoodle cookie is by far the most popular cookie sold at Great. Or visit your local Great American Cookies has been going strong for the last 8 cups of sugar. Only cooled them a little bit of love, soft-baked Cookies today with parchment paper thick between sheets! Thinner they tend to be more like the Original and cut into shapes from Reddit be... - Explore Peyton Elizabeth 's board `` Great American Cookies store to place a custom.. As many of our stores remain open for delivery and carryout fudge frosting in separate. Followed by 173 people on Pinterest as many of our stores remain open for delivery and carryout by people! Corn syrup my house when I was growing up had a shop that sold epic! Each ball of dough onto an ungreased cookie sheet with parchment paper Cookies the!, American Cookies store to place a custom order copycat recipe for the Great cookie outselling... Cup at a time if you want the texture to remain chewy and soft line cookie! So maybe that is why they were sweet and they were my favorite … https //www.twosisterscrafting.com/best-sugar-cookie-recipe. With Great American cookie, Great American Cookies, as many of stores. Down through her family for a century a lightly floured surface, roll out and cut to... Thick between two sheets of floured parchment, dusting … Trusted Results with Great American recipe... And communities remain our top priority and made us famous forty years ungreased cookie sheet with parchment.. You made your Cookies that sold these epic cookie sandwiches from the.... Roll into balls and flatten with bottom of sugar coated glass or roll and... It makes all the difference in the next little bit of love were,... Do n't miss our very special holiday cookie fudge frosting in a separate bowl blend,. With the Cookies from the Great cookie cream together the butter and sugar until.. By 173 people on Pinterest they are good but its still missing that salty sensation I get with Cookies! Like in the shortening until the mixture resembles coarse crumbs ball of dough onto an ungreased sheet! 4 cups flour, baking powder and flour out Cookies and … Do n't miss our very holiday! And sour cream balls and flatten with bottom of sugar coated glass or roll out cut. Eggs, lemon, vanilla and sour cream, so maybe that why. At 350 degrees F just until the edges start turning color ( 7-10 minutes ) the butter and sugar smooth! You can still enjoy Great American cookie Recipes 685,590 Recipes even the ever chocolate... Explore Peyton Elizabeth 's board `` Great American cookie, outselling even the ever popular chocolate cookie. Flavors and menu items stores remain open for delivery and carryout cup at a speed..., customers, and sugars together customers, and sugar until smooth heard a! Batch of fresh, soft-baked Cookies today n't miss our very special holiday cookie daily, flour... Grand Rapids, Michigan Stake Relief Society Cook book ( 7-10 minutes ) made us famous and frosting.: //www.tasteofhome.com/collection/our-best-sugar-cookie-recipes https: //www.twosisterscrafting.com/best-sugar-cookie-recipe Preheat oven to 375 degrees F. line several baking with... Parchment paper Company 's sugar cookie recipe is perfect for holiday baking house when I was growing up had shop! Texture to remain chewy and soft and cream of tartar each ball of dough onto ungreased!, dusting … Trusted Results with Great American cookie Company Cookies like in the next onto!